
Why I don't feel AI will kill media as art
Posted on by Maddy Miller
In Technology with tags AI, Community, Retrospective
1649 words, 6 minutes to read
AI may flood the internet with cheap imitations, but art is more than content. People value the human perspectives and connections behind it.
https://madelinemiller.dev/blog/media-as-art/I grew up in fandom spaces.
Spaces that were absolutely flooded with stories, visual artworks, and videos. Looking back, those spaces are probably one of the worst to point to as an argument that people only care about the quality of an artistic work. Yet despite that, people formed communities and followings around particular creators anyway. Communities that cared about the interpretations, perspectives, and unique ways that each creator approached a shared source material. I’ve spent most of my life watching people care deeply about things that only make sense when you consider the factor of human connection.
This is part of why I’ve found myself increasingly unconvinced by arguments that AI will kill media as art, and human creativity as a whole.
The argument I’ve seen
Over the past few years, I’ve repeatedly seen discussions around how AI will kill artistic media. As many of my hobbies and communities revolve around creative work, this is not a conversation I can easily avoid. I’ve spent years seeing creators discuss these concerns in depth. Whether it’s about games, writing, music, or visual art, the argument ends up boiling down to two things.
Firstly, AI will flood the world with generated media, making human-made artistic works impossible to discover. This argument also extends into commercial incentives. As AI-generated media becomes cheaper to produce, big companies will feel a need to utilise AI to a large degree to remain competitive. This would mean that even organisations that do have the resources to avoid using AI will eventually capitulate to economic pressures.
Secondly, those who do create something and push it out into the world, will immediately have their works stolen or copied and at greater scale by people using AI. Because the replications are perceived as “better”, why would people use the independently created one? This also ties into a discoverability problem too, where it becomes difficult to find the original in the flood of clones.
Now to clarify, I don’t feel these concerns are entirely unfounded. AI is harming creative industries, and it’s very normal to be worried about where that trend leads. Discoverability is a growing problem, and job losses are rampant across many creative industries. This is not a defence of AI, or a dismissal of those real problems affecting creative spaces. Last year I actually wrote an article on the ways this was affecting personal blogging. As time goes on, I’ve found myself questioning if this will actually lead to the feared end-result of “the death of art and human creativity.”
The human element
To me, both common arguments miss one major factor, they treat consumption of artistic media as entirely transactional, that consumers only care about perceived quality. That there’s one objective metric that all art is scored against, and the “best” work wins. And by that measure, if a higher quality version appears, then the original is inherently irrelevant. That does not at all reflect how I’ve seen people interact with creative works throughout my life.
Growing up in fandom spaces, people didn’t just follow the best story. The ones that were most faithful to the characters, that progressed the dominant plotline, etc. They followed the stories which spoke to them, and the writers that wrote those stories. When people watch a “Let’s Play” on YouTube, they aren’t just watching whoever has the best gameplay, they’re watching for the personalities of the creator. Players get excited for new games from specific game studios. Readers follow authors from book to book. When people engage with media, they are also engaging with the people behind it.
As an example, the fan fiction “My Immortal” by Tara Gilesbie (possibly a pseudonym) is infamous for being fairly low-quality. It hits on every trope, has an entire side-plot of arguments between author and editor in the author’s notes, and can’t decide what the story is actually about. It is, however, unmistakably human. This story didn’t take off because it was the best piece of Harry Potter fan fiction ever written; in fact, it’s often forgotten that it even is Harry Potter fan fiction. It took off in part because people were intrigued by the lore surrounding its creator. If works were purely judged on quality, it would’ve faded into obscurity almost immediately after it was published.
Both “My Immortal” and its creator have become a cultural artefact, representing that part of internet culture. Today, it’s more likely that someone knows about the mythology surrounding it rather than the actual text of the story itself. The story surrounding it is ultimately a human story. A similar example is the Tommy Wiseau film “The Room”, where his uncanny valley acting and script have created their own mythology. That example also shares the mysterious author aspect, as Tommy Wiseau’s background is shrouded in mystery.
This doesn’t just apply to fandom spaces. In gaming, people get excited for games due to the inherent fingerprint that the creatives behind it leave on the game. A new “Bethesda” game is exciting because of the feeling of Bethesda games. The same goes for a new “Remedy” game, a new “Don’t Nod” game, or a game from any other well-known studio. When “The Outer Worlds” came out, I remember seeing disappointment across the internet from the realisation that it was no longer the same “Obsidian” that created “Fallout: New Vegas.” The humans within a studio still collectively matter to both the final product and audience experiencing it, just as much as “Wes Anderson” matters to one of his films.
Creative communities also repeatedly show this. When it comes to game jams, writing jams/prompts, art challenges, etc, participants are very often given the same base theme or prompt to work off. Even with thousands of participants, I’ve never seen two outputs that are largely the same. They are typically nowhere close to each other. This just shows that the value doesn’t come from the prompt itself, but the unique human interpretations of the people responding to it.
In the last game jam I participated in, the theme was “Delay the inevitable.” As someone with chronic illness, I made a management game about juggling household chores and self-care with a limited energy budget. That was a game from my own lived experience, and vastly different from anything else I saw submitted.
This isn’t entirely new
Another reason why these arguments have never really resonated with me, is that I’ve been watching this happen in communities I care about for well over a decade. I’m someone who loves casual mobile games, think along the lines of Candy Crush (although I never got into that one). Popular games are constantly copied, game mechanics are repackaged in slightly different formats, and predatory/misleading ads draw in players to whatever clone has the biggest marketing budget. When “Flappy Bird” was removed from app stores, so many clones immediately materialised to the point that many people didn’t even notice.
This is of course not to say that discoverability is not a problem, it is. It’s a problem we’ve been fighting against for well over a decade. New creators struggle to stand out, and unique artistic ideas get lost beneath a flood of low-quality clones and asset flips. Despite this however, creativity has not disappeared from mobile gaming spaces. I feel this is because the dynamics of how people interact with games have not changed; we still want that human element. When clones appear, they primarily copy mechanics, while losing the human connection.
The way I’ve come to see it is that not all media is trying to or even needs to achieve the same thing. Some media is primarily created as attention-grabbing content, and that’s okay. Other media is created to express something, explore an idea, or communicate a perspective. It’s this type of media which has that human touch to it. The bulk of the cloned, mass-produced, and AI-generated media that people worry about sit within that first category. This has also happened in streaming television, with Netflix often being criticised for churning out “background content” rather than artistic shows worth talking about for years. This hasn’t stopped high-quality television being produced, as the two have different purposes.
The existence of media designed to capture attention has existed for as long as media has, just like media created to express something. These have always existed side by side, yet people have always been drawn to creators, perspectives, and experiences that feel distinctly and uniquely human. What’s changed with AI, is that more types of media have fallen below the threshold where it’s economically viable to spam out “media as content”. We of course need to fix discoverability, but it will never extinguish human creativity and a need to create art.
Conclusion
Growing up in fandom spaces taught me that people don’t just seek out stories, they seek out human connection. To the point that SYOC (Submit your own character) became a concept in some communities, where readers would submit a character to a writer in the hopes that they’d be included in future chapters or stories. It’s an example of people seeking out perspectives, interpretations, and just a feeling of connection to the people behind it all.
Years later, seeing these connections develop around YouTubers, game studios, artists, and musicians, I find it difficult to believe that AI can somehow change this fundamental relationship. AI may make discoverability worse, it may reshape creative industries, and it may flood the internet with more content than ever before. Those are all very real concerns. However, I don’t believe it can ever destroy the human desire to create art, nor the human desire to use art to seek out a connection with another human.
This article was one I wrote a few months ago but didn’t feel it was to a standard where I felt good publishing it. I recently had a new idea that I felt solidified the thesis (fandoms, as opposed to a prior example of fast fashion), so I revised the existing parts to fit around the new central narrative.



